Kestrel Expert Advisor Drawdown and Worst Floating Loss

Nobody should call any grid expert advisor safe, so this page publishes the opposite: the worst moment of every Kestrel strategy and of three sets of four in the 2014–2025 backtest, the floating loss and the fall from the equity peak, each with its date, and the capital requirements those moments set.

See pricing and licence levels

Kestrel holding position in strong wind over a dark sea

Worst floating loss vs drawdown

A grid expert advisor adds to a losing position instead of closing it, so the usual risk numbers describe it badly; two measurements describe it properly, and they are not the same thing.

The worst floating loss is how far the open baskets were under water at their single worst instant; the drawdown is how far equity dropped below its own previous high. The larger of the two, the worst case, is what the capital requirements are built on.

Kestrel EA is a grid expert advisor for MetaTrader 4: it opens from its own signal, adds to the basket in small, capped steps when price moves against it, and closes the whole basket together at its target. It has no stop loss: until the basket closes the loss is floating, and the account can lose its whole balance (stop-out).

The worst moment of each strategy

Technical information about the software, the same for everyone. Not financial advice and not tailored to your situation. The decision is yours.

Backtest 2014–2025, Horizon level, account in euros, one common window for every row:

Strategy or setWorst floating loss (date)Deepest fall from an equity peakWorst case
AUDCAD Patient−€2,247, 26 Jun 2023€2,231€2,247
EURUSD Patient−€2,929, 11 Mar 2025€2,928€2,929
EURCAD Patient−€3,811, 13 Mar 2017€3,786€3,811
GBPUSD Patient−€4,326, 14 Nov 2024€4,312€4,326
AUDCAD Active−€5,033, 4 Mar 2016€5,018€5,033
EURUSD Active−€5,198, 18 May 2017€5,178€5,198
EURCAD Active−€6,584, 13 Mar 2017€6,550€6,584
GBPUSD Active−€7,057, 31 Jul 2020€7,025€7,057
EURUSD Patient + GBPUSD Patient + EURCAD Patient + AUDCAD Patient−€5,698, 6 Mar 2025€5,557€5,698
EURUSD Active + AUDCAD Active + EURCAD Patient + GBPUSD Patient−€7,820, 14 Nov 2024€7,701€7,820
EURUSD Active + GBPUSD Active + EURCAD Active + AUDCAD Active−€8,878, 14 Nov 2024€8,737€8,878

Hypothetical results. Hypothetical or simulated performance results have certain limitations. These results are simulated (backtest 2014–2025) and do not represent actual trading. Because the trades were not actually executed, the results may have under- or over-compensated for the impact, if any, of certain market factors, such as lack of liquidity, slippage, swap and commission, none of which are included.

Simulated trading programs are also designed with the benefit of hindsight. No representation is being made that any account will or is likely to achieve profits or losses similar to those shown. Past or simulated results are not a reliable indicator of future results.

Risk warning. Kestrel has no stop loss. Leveraged forex trading can lose the whole balance of the account, and a worse moment than any in the backtest remains possible.

In every row the worst case is the floating reading, not the fall from a peak. A set is measured as one account, hour by hour, so its worst moment is smaller than the worst moments of its strategies added up, but the strategies of a set can and did have bad days together: two of the three sets above reached their worst moment on the same day.

From the worst moment to the capital requirements

The capital requirements are fixed multiples of the worst case, the same for everyone: the technical minimum is the smallest balance a broker would not have stopped out at that moment, at 1:500 leverage, and the tight and ample buffers are two and three times the worst case. For EURUSD Active + AUDCAD Active + EURCAD Patient + GBPUSD Patient at Horizon (backtest 2014–2025) that is a technical minimum of €8,500 (€9,500 at a 50 % stop-out), a tight buffer of €16,000 and an ample buffer of €23,500, set by the −€7,820 of 14 November 2024.

Summit scales the starting lot by five and Zenith by ten, so the same episode costs five or ten times as much and every requirement moves by the same factor. Every set of one to four strategies is on Kestrel Strategy Combinations: Technical Capital Requirements, and the calculation on Kestrel EA Risk Management and Capital Requirements for MT4.

Account requirements

Technical account requirements: MetaTrader 4; an account that allows hedging (buy and sell positions open at the same time); server time NY+7; account in EUR or USD; stop-out at 20 % (Standard accounts) or 50 % (Raw/ECN accounts). Requirements are calculated at 1:500 leverage. With EU-regulated brokers the maximum for retail clients is 1:30, and the capital needed is higher. The choice of broker and of its protections is yours.

What these numbers do not cover

Swap, commission and slippage are not in the backtest, and a future episode worse than any in the sample remains possible. Beyond the backtest, the software has run as a forward test on demo since September 2026, not on a real account.

The strategy behind the figures is on Kestrel Grid EA for MT4: Expert Advisor With Controlled Lots and the generic mechanics on Grid Trading Strategy: Rules, Risks and Lot Sizing.

Frequently asked questions

What was the worst floating loss in the backtest?

For EURUSD Patient alone it was −€2,929 on 11 March 2025; for EURUSD Active + AUDCAD Active + EURCAD Patient + GBPUSD Patient it was −€7,820 on 14 November 2024. Both are from the backtest 2014–2025, Horizon level, account in euros, hypothetical.

Is the worst floating loss the same thing as maximum drawdown?

No. The worst floating loss measures how far the open baskets were under water at one instant; the drawdown measures how far equity dropped below its previous high. The larger of the two, the worst case, sets the capital requirements.

Why does Kestrel never show a losing basket?

Because it has no stop loss: it holds losing baskets open until they close at their target, so the risk stays floating instead of showing as closed losses. That is why this page leads with the floating figures, and why an account can still lose its whole balance.

See pricing and licence levels

Last updated: